• Mon, May 14 2007

You’re a Nice Looking Blog – Who Owns You?

I do understand that people can have a range of perfectly rational reasons for having anonymous blogs, for example people who are concerned that they could lose their jobs if their true identity were known.

Such as the anonymous waiter behind the long-established and compulsively readable Waiter Rant.

And see the fascinating array of blogs at Work-Related Blogs and News, a site I came across via an article by Heather Green in BusinessWeek Online -Workblogging Blog: A Treasure Trove of Anonymous Blogs - where she describes the site as follows: 

The blogs tend to organize by similar jobs or writing styles. There are groups of teachers, groups of healthcare workers, groups of police and EMTs, groups of call center employees. It’s hard to know from reading them how much of these blogs are true and how much are fiction. But they’re great reading.

Great reading indeed. And all the ones I checked out were anonymous - that is, they had an obviously “made-up” nickname, with little or no bio information. When you read some of the blogs there you understand why, if they are true rather than fiction, the authors are being quite smart in not revealing their identity.

But I find it surprising and sometimes irritating to come across a blog which looks and reads as if it is meant to be a serious contender as a business blog, but gives no indication of who the owner is.

Or where the link to the “about” page is not obvious.

Or where you can find the “about” link but when you get to the page it is a basic blurb about a company, such as you would get in a brochure, but with nothing to give you a clue about who the “I” is of the blog posts.

Why put all the effort in, if no one except your family and a few close friends can work out who you are? 

I raised this issue of the anonymous or practically anonymous business blog with some colleagues recently. From a couple of comments I received, it appears that sometimes, even when people have put plenty of work into setting up and posting to their blogs, they just haven’t got around to providing some information about who they are, why they are blogging and what they are planning to provide in the blog.

For anyone authoring a business blog, a suggestion would be to ask a colleague or friend who hasn’t seen the blog before to check it out and provide some feedback, especially about their impression of how informative the blog is about the writer or writer.

Around The Web
Share This Post:
  • Pingback: Speedlinking - 16 May 2007

  • http://www.netwriting.co.uk/ richard

    I agree its nice to see whose writing the blog, I think its important to develop long term relationship. Picture helps too.

    It’s also good when comments have a real name. I think it’s funny how many, Mr Credit Cards, there are these days :)

  • http://idiotaffiliate.com Leo Dimilo

    I was a server in a past life…I totally understand why that person would want to remain anonymous

  • http://www.whatudidtoday.com delani

    I run a website where some of the submissions are sent anonymous for various reasons. I understand why some people may want to comment anonymously or without their real name.

    By the same token, I do agree with Richard about not wanting spammy names in the comment section, either. For all I know, there is a Mr. MasterCard and Mrs. Visa Credit Card who just had a lot of kids into internet stuff. :)

  • http://earsucker.com Roberta

    I had a blog about work once (I’m a bill collector–run now) :) I was totally and completely anonymous, but everything I wrote in there was true. I wasn’t looking to reveal my identity on that blog because of where I work….I’d probably get fired.

  • http://www.pddoc.com/copyright/genealogy_copyright_fundamentals.htm Mike in Arkansas

    I guess for me, I’ve been just a little uncomfortable placing my name out there on the internet where anyone can find it, so I decided to do a search on my name to see how much was out there.

    Turns out there is 588 hits for my name on Google.

    The number one hit is an article, Copyright Fundamentals for Genealogy, which is good because that is mine.

    The second one is on iMBd movies for a bit part in Field of Dreams — not me.

    Third is a Sr. Security Ananlyst at Tech Data Corporation — not me.

    The 3rd, 4th, and 5th hits are from my blog(s).

    Then there is

    - the astrophysicist at University of Leicester, UK.
    - the guy in West Virginia that won the $100,000 Powerball prize
    - an actor in a movie about Lincoln being sold on Amazon, and much, much more

    I guess there are so many of “me” that it really doesn’t matter.

    In actuality, though, I’ve been using my name lately more often than not.

    Why not — who’s to know which me it really is?

    Mike Goad

  • http://www.kineda.com Terry Ng

    ghostbloggers! :D

  • http://www.deswalsh.com Des Walsh

    Mike
    You’ve put your finger on something very important. Apart from the odd Kalahari Bushman and a couple of goatherders in Outer Mongolia, we all have or will very soon have an online identity. We do have a choice is whether it will be the identity we have written and promoted, or someone else’s, or one that’s out of date. In business, surely we want to manage this process, not just let it happen? I feel a blog post on this coming on :)

  • http://prairiebluestem.blogspot.com/ Genevieve Netz

    I’ve blogged with my real name since I started my blog about a year and a half ago. I have nothing to hide. I wanted to claim what I wrote.

  • http://xmasb.com XmasB

    I use a nick because people don’t need to know who I am. Basically I do this for almost everything I do on the net. If you search for my name on google, you will find only 93 results. Most of them are not me. I try to keep my name off the web, because people don’t need to know more about me. If I would apply for a job, my future employer doesn’t need to read through my blog and comments on the web.

    My personal life is personal. I want it to remain that way. I may use my real name after a while, but I prefer to keep my nick as long as i can.

    I agree that a blogger with an identity and picture seems more serious, but for now I think the drawbacks greater than the benefits.

    This post made me rethink it though. I may “reveal” myself some day.

  • http://exit78.com Mike Goad

    Any future employer would be welcome to read through anything that I’ve written. Of course, I don’t expect that to be a problem, because I’m retired and don’t plan to be applying for any jobs.

    That the use of a real name seems more serious is something that I hadn’t considered. In my posts and my comments, I try to be serious and I try to contribute something, even if it’s nothing more than thanking the writer.

    I also try to be disciplined in how I say things in my posts and comments. I don’t write anything that I’d be concerned about my wife, daughters, or parents coming across.

  • http://www.mikekunz.com Mike

    I’m just starting a website and I’m going to make it a point to evaluate what I write so it does not compromise my employment or Family. I’m using my real name.

  • http://funuselessstuff.blogspot.com/2007/05/surrogate-pimp.html Surrogate Pimp

    All right, I’ll reveal my true identity.

    …I’m Batman.

  • http://leuropa.eu/ Robert Redl

    I could imagine a lot of reasons for ano-bloggers, but nowadays in europe the laws are getting stricter each day,and therefore everybody must have an about or imprint page and is even not allowed to give a p/o box – it must be a normal postal address. The funny thing for the paranoic is: If your web is about social or politic things, then you have to give moreinformation. And right now the laws about data-retention are starting, which means a minimum of 6months, where all connection related data has to be keptby law on the provider side. I am sure that content retention will follow. Greetings from Europe – Section 1984 ;-)

  • http://walkin.wordpress.com Job Blogger

    I would also like to reveal my identity asap.

  • http://www.deswalsh.com Des Walsh

    Job Blogger
    To start, you could just add your name and some info to your About Us page. Wouldn’t that help job seekers have more confidence that someone real was in charge of the site? I can understand anonymity if this is just a sideline and you are working in a day job for a competitor, but if you want to claim more market share and you are independent, surely it would help to have a more personal identity than Job Blogger? It would be good if you could share your thoughts on that – I for one would be interested.

  • http://www.deswalsh.com Des Walsh

    XmasB
    Thanks for your thoughtful observations. You make a great point about people who are wanting to stay employed or be employed in the future – it might not be a good idea to be personally identifiable. My point was not so much about being ‘serious” but about blogs which are intended as marketing tools and what they say about “brand You” or about you as the owner of the business you are effectively wanting people to trust as a provider of goods or services, and about your values, what is important to you about customer service and so on – quite a different set of processes from what happens with an anonymous website/blog, or even a “character” blog where the “author” is actually a construct by the marketing department. For me, it all comes down to how much or how little real engagement I as a business owner want with my clients and those I would like to attract to be my clients.

  • http://thearticlewriter.com/blog/2007/05/22/on-the-block-cfac/ Matt Keegan

    I have a friend who wants to start blogging, but is terrified that she will be found out. She is the type of person who likes to “tell it as it is” which is just the type of speech that may land her in a heap of trouble.

    I think Blogger is the best venue for creating a free, anonymous blog.

  • http://www.deswalsh.com Des Walsh

    Matt
    I do think that even people who, like your friend, have a reason to blog anonymously need to recognise the capacity of governmnents or companies/people with wealth to find them. Whether rightly or wrongly, Yahoo is accused of helping the Chinese government jail dissidents – http://blogs.business2.com/business2blog/2006/02/yahoo_helps_jai.html – and in Australia the multimillionaire Dick Smith was prepared to spend a lot of his money to find an “anonymous” commenter on a blog and get an apology at least. I think we who understand the limitations of “anonymous” blogging should let our friends know that their ‘anonymity’ might not be foolproof. Again, for a business I really don’t see the point of anonymous blogging.

  • http://www.deswalsh.com Des Walsh

    Here’s a link to the story of Dick Smith tracking down the “anonymous” commenter http://www.dilanchian.com.au/content/view/168/36/. And if anyone thinks that what the Australian legal system does is of no concern in other countries, I suggest they talk to the folks at Dow Jones – see http://tinyurl.com/yt4xhf