Funniest Blog Comment Ev-ah
November 8, 2007 by Jodie Lynn Boduch
Filed under Baseball, Sports Rumors
Dear readers, we beg encourage you to leave comments. There are some true gems to be had in the comments section of a blog, and here’s your inspiration.
Perceptive Prospero sent this to us. It’s from Curt Schilling’s 38 Pitches blog under the 2003 Opening Letter post. Very big wish-we-thought-of-it thumbs up to commenter #39 (menuhub) for making us laugh.
Yanks fans, this is your last chance to turn back. Read at your own risk. Sox fans, Yanks haters, and those keen for cleverness, carefully place your hot beverage away from your keyboard and DO NOT reach for it while reading menuhub’s post:
YANKfAN22 Please take a few moments to fill out the conversion form below to help us get to know you better and prescribe any required counseling to recover from your previous fan experience.
Name: __________yankfan22_____________
Address:______________________________
Who’s Your Daddy: ____________________
1. Please select your favorite recent Yankee new player acquisition:
[ ] Roger Clemens $20 million, six wins, one groin pull
[ ] Alex Rodriquez $92 million, no title, Ha!
[ ] Derek Jeter $123 million since last won world series
[ ] Jason Giambi $91 million, no title, lots of roid sweat
[ ] Carl Pavano $27 million, five wins
2. . Which of the following would you most like to see as the most played YES Network “Great Moments in Yankee History” film clip in 2008:
[ ] Rivera’s “shocking” blown save in Game 4, 2004
[ ] Rivera’s “shocking” blown save in Game 5, 2004
[ ] The awesome wild card clincher celebration
[ ] Wang getting hammered in Game 1
[ ] Wang getting hammered in Game 2
[ ] Jeter’s first GIDP
[ ] Jeter’s second GIDP
[ ] Jeter’s third GIDP
3. Please indicate the last book you read:
[ ] Someday, in my lifetime, the Yankees will get to the LCS
[ ] Suicide Hotline – It’s not just for Cubs’ fans anymore
[ ] The Heimlich Maneuver — What to do when choking
4. Which recent Yankees personnel move did you enjoy most:
[ ] Not winning the posting for Matsuzaka
[ ] Winning the posting for Kei Igawa
5. Which following designation best describes Derek Jeter’s performance in this year’s ALDS:
[ ] Captain Intangibles
[ ] Captain GIDP
[ ] Captain & Tenille
6. Please choose your favorite movie:
[ ] Anger Management
[ ] Hunt for Red October
[ ] Damned Yankees
[ ] Still We Believe
7. Finish this sentence: “Alex Rodriquez is
a. overrated
b. overpaid
c. overdue
d. overly prissy
e. over
8. Select the most vociferous, stupid, and annoying Yankee fan:
[ ] Washed up “comic” hack and Yanks personal ballwasher Billy Crystal
[ ] Front-running celebrity phony Jack Nicholson
[ ] Tim McCarver
9 . Are you ready to admit that :
a. Ted Williams was better than Joe DiMaggio?
b. Carlton Fisk was better than Thurman Munson?
c. Even Manny Ramirez is faster than Bernie Williams?
d. Reggie Jackson was a better outfielder than Matsui?
e. Derek Jeter has less range than a kumquat
f. No self-respecting parasite would invade Jason Giambi?
10. Please indicate your favorite moments in Yankee history: (Check all that apply):
[ ] Alex Rodriquez is traded to the Yankees
[ ] Don Mattingly never wins a World Series
[ ] The Yankees let Clemens get away
[ ] The Yankees get Clemens back
[ ] Giambi’s steroid abuse causes his body to collapse like a screen door in a hurricane.
[ ] The bugs eat Joba
11 . Have you experienced any of the following after the embarrassing four game collapse? (Check all that apply)
[ ] Headache
[ ] Uncontrolled Anger
[ ] Heartache
[ ] Holes punched in doors or walls
[ ] Nausea
[ ] Smashed TV screens
[ ] Depression and Broken Dreams
[ ] Avoided Red Sox fans for days or weeks
Once you have completed this form, please forward it to Fenway Park.
Then burn all your remaining Yankee clothing, memorabilia, and associated reminders. After reviewing your request, the Red Sox Fan Club will contact you with notification of acceptance or rejection.
I hereby acknowledge that the real “curse” is being a Yankee Fan.
I hereby renounce the New York Yankees for all eternity on this the ______ day of ________________, 200__















That is good. Whoa creativity – gotta hand it to the commenter.
Okay I left a comment just for you
It’s all going to be so different now that Boss George has donated the Yankees to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. This is breaking news and too wonderful for words. I’m proud to say we at eTrueSports.com broke the story that will benefit all of mankind:
Tampa, FL – BREAKING NEWS – In a move that shocked the baseball world – not to mention his sons – George Steinbrenner is insisting that he will make good on his previous pledge to donate the New York Yankees to the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and that Bill Gates, not Joe Girardi, is the team’s manager. (more)
Erica–If we could only get that guy to write a good one for tennis . . .
Jennifer–Love that deadpan humor! And thanks for the comment. We feel loved. (Sure, that’s a foreign concept, but still).
Frank–That does it, we’re officially going to stalk your site for cool hoax stories. Good stuff!
This blog is inspiring me, thanks.