2009 NHL Awards Nominees and Predictions
April 29, 2009 by Jeanne Dupuis
Filed under Goals, Injuries, Minnesota Wild, NHL, NHL Playoffs, News, Players, Scores
The finalists for the Vezina, Norris, Calder, Selke and Lady Byng Memorial Trophies have been chosen. I will update this post as more nominees are announced. The winners will be revealed at the 2009 NHL Awards which will be broadcast from Las Vegas, NV on June 18, 2009. I’m going to list my predictions in each category but feel free to let me know who you think will win in the comments area!
VEZINA TROPHY
The possible Vezina Trophy (top goaltender) winners include Tim Thomas (Boston Bruins), Niklas Backstrom (Minnesota Wild) and rookie Steve Mason (Columbus Blue Jackets). I think that all three of these finalists have a shot for different reasons.
- Tim Thomas finished the season with a 2.10 GAA and helped the Bruins become the team with the second-best record in the league. He’s also been good in the postseason where his team swept the Montreal Canadiens in the first round.
- Mason had a GAA of 2.29 and he was truly impressive throughout the year considering the fact that he is a rookie and has been battling mononucleosis. He was pretty abysmal, however, in the playoffs and the Columbus Blue Jackets made an early exit.
- Backstrom finished the season with a 2.33 GAA but the Minnesota Wild failed to make the playoffs. Still, of the three finalists he had the most wins with 37, making him the fifth most winningest goalie in the league.
MY PREDICTION: Thomas. He was solid this season and so was his team and I think that will give him the edge he needs to take home the Vezina.
image: TSN
NORRIS TROPHY
The finalists for the Norris Trophy (top defenseman) are Zdeno Chara (Boston Bruins), Mike Green (Washington Capitals) and Nicklas Lidstrom (Detroit Red Wings).
- Chara is arguably the best player on the Bruins and the captain has done an excellent job leading his team to the top spot in the Eastern Conference this season. He has had more ice time than his fellow finalists with an average of 26:04 per game and had 19 goals (fourth best among NHL defensemen) and 31 assists, leaving him with 50 points.
- Green led the defenders with 31 goals and 73 points but really made his presence known during Washington’s power play since 18 of those goals were scored on a man-advantage. That ranked second to superstar teammate, Alexander Ovechkin, best among NHL defensemen and fourth among all players. He is also tied with fellow finalist, Lidstrom, for third most game-winning goals (4). He sets himself apart, however, with his 86 hits, 110 blocked shots and 49 takeaways.
- Lidstrom is a leader on the Wings as he has been for years. In the 17 seasons he’s played since entering the NHL in 1991, he’s only missed 32 games which speaks volumes about his durability. I can’t stand Detroit but this man needs to be recognized for the amazing player that he is. He’s also just a really great skater with excellent hand-eye coordination. He logged 16 goals and 43 assists for a total of 59 points this season.
MY PREDICTION: This is a tough one. I really am having a hard time choosing but since I have to pick just one person, I’m going to say Chara.
CALDER TROPHY
The nominees for the Calder Trophy (top rookie) this year are Steve Mason (goaltender, Columbus Blue Jackets), Bobby Ryan (Anaheim Ducks) and Kris Versteeg (Chicago Blackhawks).
- Mason had a history-making season and has done better than some of the greats (Brodeur, Roy, Sawchuk, etc…). The kid, who battled mononucleosis toward the end of the season, recorded 10 shutouts (#1 in the league), ranked second with a 2.29 save percentage, eighth with 3,664 minutes, ninth with 33 wins, 10th with 61 games and 11th with a .916 save percentage. Unfortunately, the fairytale fell apart in the postseason…
- Ryan was drafted in the 2005 Entry Draft (#2 behind Sidney Crosby) and finally, he got to play this year after spending two more years in the junior league (although, he did begin the season in the AHL since the Ducks had no room in the salary cap for him). He led all NHL rookies with 31 goals and 57 points. He also had an impressive 17.8 shooting % from 174 shots. The rookie also led the Ducks with a plus-13 rating and 12 power-play goals (17th overall in the NHL).
- Versteeg registered 22 goals and led all NHL rookies with 31 assists. He also ranked fourth among rookies with a plus –15 rating. He has incredible puckhandling ability and led the Blackhawks and tied for fourth in the NHL with four shorthanded goals. Ryan and Versteeg tied for second among NHL rookies with three game-winning goals.
MY PREDICTION: Bobby Ryan, especially given his team’s surprising performance during the quarterfinals.
SELKE TROPHY
The Selke Trophy (top defensive forward) will be awarded to one of the following players: Pavel Datsyuk (Detroit Red Wings), Ryan Kesler (Vancouver Canucks) or Mike Richards (Philadelphia Flyers).
- Datsyuk has a lot of desirable qualities (see all the good stuff I wrote about him in the Lady Bing section below) but he has a chance at winning this award for the second time because he really is a smart player. He pays attention to his own game play and that of his opponents and he tries to improve himself accordingly. As such, it’s hard for rivals to know exactly what he’s going to do and part of that is because he’s so quick in getting in on the forecheck. In comparison with his competition for this award, Datsyuk outscored both Richards and Kesler by logging 32 goals and 65 assists for 97 points (4th in the NHL). Datsyuk was third in the NHL with a plus-34 rating and won 56% of his faceoffs (9th overall).
- Kesler brings intensity to the game both physically and emotionally. He makes his presence known and he definitely knows how to bring out anger in his opponents. Kesler might be the most versatile of these three nominees because he’s able to center a checking line or play the rugged forward on the right side of the first line with the Sedin twins. His stats aren’t as great as those of Datsyuk or Richards but this award isn’t all about the numbers – it’s also about having good judgment and being a keen observer. Kesler finished the regular season with 26 goals and 33 assists for 59 points (63rd overall) but he had a plus –8 rating, two shorthanded goals, blocked 77 shots and won 54% of his faceoffs.
- Richards was named an alternate captain for the Flyers last season but was promoted to captain before the season began. You only need to watch a few games to see his clear leadership qualities. He led the team in assists, takeaways (83) and faceoff percentage. He also led the league with seven shorthanded goals and had the best season of his career with 30 goals, 50 assists and a plus-22 rating. He also managed to block 90 shots and had 147 hits (33rd in the league).
MY PREDICTION: Kesler. He may not have the numbers on paper but I think that he has shown how strong he is as a player and I think it made a difference in Vancouver’s push to the playoffs.
LADY BYNG MEMORIAL TROPHY
This year’s Lady Byng Memorial (for sportsmanship) nominees are Martin St. Louis (Tampa Bay Lightning), Pavel Datsyuk (Detroit Red Wings) and Zach Parise (New Jersey Devils).
- Datsyuk could be the first player since Boucher in 1931 to win the Lady Byng four times in a row. He’s got some impressive numbers to go along with his good behavior. He led the Red Wings with 65 assists (fifth in the league) and 97 points (4th overall) and was third on his team with 32 goals. He was instrumental to his team’s power-play success with 11 goals and 25 assists for a total of 36 power-play points. As if that wasn’t enough, the mid-sized player managed to block 33 shots.
- Parise had quite a year during his fourth season in the NHL. He played his 300th game, got his 100th goal and 200th point. The Devils can thank him for his big effort in improving their offensive attack – he took an amazing 364 shots which is the third-highest in the NHL. He also played in every game and finished the season with 45 goals (3rd in the league) and 95 points (5th overall). He also had 14 power-play goals, eight game-winners and spent just 24 minutes in the penalty box. Pretty saintly, if you ask me.
- St. Louis is one of those rare spirited players that somehow manages to avoid taking penalties. Maybe it’s because he’s smaller than the average player (5-foot-9 and 177 pounds) or he really could just be a nice guy. Whatever the reason, he’s never spent more than 38 minutes in the box in 10 NHL seasons which is downright incredible. Also, despite the fact that his team was doing extremely poorly this year, he kept his head in the game and led the Lightning with 30 goals (seven on the PP and three game-winners), 50 assists and 80 points.
MY PREDICTION: I think that Parise has a good shot because he had an overall great season but there’s something to be said about a player who continues to work hard on a team that’s slowly sinking like St. Louis. Still, if you look at the points-per-penalty minute ratio, St. Louis produced 5.71 points per penalty minute; Datsyuk, 4.4 and Parise, 3.96. Maybe that will give St. Louis enough edge to win.

















Vezina- Tim Thomas. He played fantastic this year and is one of the main reasons the Bruins are the force they are.
Norris- Nick Lidstrom. The best ever at his position, period. Chara had a good year, and Green had an outstanding year, but the bottom line is when you break down the complete numbers (goals,assists, and more importantly +/-), nick is still the best hands down. Ask any player in the league who they would least like to see when they play, its Lidstrom.
Calder- Ryan. He has great skill and movess the puck well.
Selke- Datsyuk. There is not a more complete player in the game, he’s a force on offense and defense. Take aways are top 3 every year.
Land Bing- who cares, this is hockey not ice dancing.
I would be curious to know why you “can’t stand Detroit.” Does perfection scare you? Or is it because Stanley likes being here?
insert foot in mouth, brasco616! If they’re so perfect why’d they blow a 2-0 series lead and a game 7 at home? I have no doubt they’ll be back next year, but as Babcock said, they were “out of gas’
brasco616 – those are really good selections for good reasons. Some of these were really tough for me to call but I have to agree with you. Lidstrom is an excellent player.
As for the Wings, you have totally busted me. It’s because Stanley likes it there too much
I did live outside Detroit for two years so I should be a little more loyal.
This isn’t a comment on the awards selections, this is just something I have to get off my chest before I explode. I have been a hockey fan ever since the wings took Yzerman in 1983. Football was always my #1 sport, but hockey took that over becasue I love the skill, speed, hitting, and fighting. I’ve even overlooked some of the stupid rule changes (if it ain’t broke don’t fix it) and the addition of another ref (who clogs up the ice every game). But the officiating in these playoffs have been beyond awful. Game 3 of the redwing series is the tip of the iceberg, and as i’m watching the capitals/penguins game 3, a very soft penalty was called at 5 minutes of the third in a 1-1 game. In the past someone had to be bleeding or missing a tooth for that kind of call in the third period of a playoff game. I’m just very dissapointed in the way hockey is going, and if they ban fighting then I’m out all together. Analyst’s like Mike milbury doesn’t make it any better. Why he is a commentater is beyond me. He sucked as a coach, he sucked as a GM, and he’s an even worst analyst. Just watch him, you’ll see what I mean. Anyway, that’s my rant.
brasco616 – you know what? You’ve written about something we can actually agree on. That Caps/Pens series is pretty ridiculous in terms of officiating when you compare it to the other playoff games. It’s so clear that the league is treating those teams (and Crosby and Ovechkin) differently.
I also agree that if they ban fighting, I’m seriously finished with hockey too. I hate what has happened to the sport and most of the new rules suck, especially since they are only enforced part of the time.
Its all about ryan XD
vezina thomas without a doubt
norris im a bruins fan so id liek chara but atleast lidstrom over green
calder mason for not being able to win the vezina with 10 shutouts on a young team
byng and selke datsyuk without a doubt… its sad to say detroit couldnt win with the best offensive and defensive players in the league… osgood is getting old if only detroit coulda borrowed timmy
Pat:
Detroit did not lose on account of Osgood. The play-off numbers he posted were outstanding and without a doubt far superior than those of his opponent, 12 years his junior. The Wings were tired and they were outplayed. They are argubly a more talented team but if the stars aren’t aligned, you aren’t going to win. The Pens came in with a better game plan and more grit. They got the job done, and they desevered their reward.
Thomas
Lidstrom
Mason
Datsyuk
Datsyuk
Enough with the rule changing. Leave it where it is. Fighting is integral and a part of the sport. I believe this with my whole being…and I’m a girl.
We seem to have some similar picks for tonight… except I believe Datsyuk’s got the Selke and Byng and Mason for Calder.
As if the only time you spelled “Lady Byng” right was in the part you copy-pasted.
Bush.
Ken, how kind of you to point out the imperfections of people