Hall of Fame Voting: A Closer Look
January 8, 2008 by Geoff Young
Filed under Hall of Fame
Okay, here’s the full vote. My thoughts below the table…
2008 Hall of Fame Vote
Player
Votes
Pct
Courtesy MLB.com.
Rich Gossage
466
85.8%
Jim Rice
392
72.2%
Andre Dawson
358
65.9%
Bert Blyleven
336
61.9%
Lee Smith
235
43.3%
Jack Morris
233
42.9%
Tommy John
158
29.1%
Tim Raines
132
24.3%
Mark McGwire
128
23.6%
Alan Trammell
99
18.2%
Dave Concepcion
88
16.2%
Don Mattingly
86
15.8%
Dave Parker
82
15.1%
Dale Murphy
75
13.8%
Harold Baines
28
5.2%
Rod Beck
2
0.4%
Travis Fryman
2
0.4%
Robb Nen
2
0.4%
Shawon Dunston
1
0.2%
Chuck Finley
1
0.2%
David Justice
1
0.2%
Chuck Knoblauch
1
0.2%
Todd Stottlemyre
1
0.2%
Jose Rijo
0
0%
Brady Anderson
0
0%
As promised, my take:
The voters finally stopped screwing Goose Gossage. This business about Bruce Sutter paving the way for him is absolute garbage. Gossage came first and was a better pitcher.
They completely dropped the ball on Tim Raines. There is no way in Hades that Jim Rice was a better player than Raines. Why folks in charge of this sort of …read more
When It Raines, It Pours
December 27, 2007 by Geoff Young
Filed under Hall of Fame, Personalities, Stats and Analysis
Dan McLaughlin has a nice article up at Hardball Times (full disclosure: I contribute to THT) on the Hall of Fame worthiness of Tim Raines. In it, Dan compares Raines to other great “tablesetters” — guys whose skills were best suited to the top of the order — throughout baseball history.
The most important finding is that Raines hangs pretty well with his contemporaries — Tony Gwynn, Rickey Henderson, and Paul Molitor. I didn’t get to see Henderson and Molitor play much until later in their careers, but I watched a lot of Gwynn and Raines. As a huge Gwynn …read more
Hall of Fame: Who Do You Like in ‘08?
December 26, 2007 by Geoff Young
Filed under Hall of Fame
I’ve been meaning to say something about the Hall of Fame for a while. To help us out, Sean Forman has created nice little reports for batters and pitchers eligible in the current balloting.
{democracy:31}
Of the new guys, Tim Raines absolutely belongs. Not sure? Several respected analysts have developed a web site that presents a compelling case for Raines. His biggest misfortune, of course, was playing opposite Rickey Henderson for most of his career. That and being buried in Montreal.
Of the holdovers, Bert Blyleven and Goose Gossage deserve enshrinement (and both are long overdue, IMHO). My guess is that one will …read more
Nine Holiday Wishes for Baseball
December 23, 2007 by Geoff Young
Filed under Odds and Ends
For your amusement, and mine…
More great games, fewer Congressional investigations.
A commissioner who isn’t one of the owners. Yeah, I know technically he isn’t one of the owners anymore, but he’s one of the owners.
Hall of Fame enshrinement for Bert Blyleven, Goose Gossage, and Tim Raines.
Enough with the Red Sox already. It was kinda cute the first time, but now it’s just annoying.
A real owner for the Marlins, and not someone who only knows how to destroy big-league franchises.
One more season for Julio Franco.
Seventy wins for the Royals and Pirates.
No domed stadiums, designated hitters, or All-Star games that determine home-field advantage …read more






